Provided the shocking and sensationalistic mother nature of the subject make any difference, even though, it’s tricky to shake the feeling that this most likely ought to have been an episode of “Dateline NBC” or some other genuine-crime series. Aerial footage, reenactments, and some overlong and repetitive interviews fill the story out to attribute size. And nevertheless, it’s challenging to shake the feeling of disappointment that lingers afterward, as properly as the unsettling reminder of the evil that exists in this environment.
Just after Tonya Hughes died from her injuries at age 20, some of her fellow dancers at Passions strip club in Tulsa attempted to contact her mother. What they realized from that phone was that their deceased friend’s name was not actually Tonya Hughes. So, who was she? Getting to the bottom of that mystery has perplexed outdated pals and veteran investigators alike for decades.
With out supplying also considerably away—because you definitely really should expertise these horrors and revelations for by yourself if you select to observe this—Tonya and her more mature, overprotective husband, Clarence, lived many life less than a lot of names in quite a few states across the region. Who they introduced themselves as various from location to place, based on their requires at the moment. Higher school good friends in Forest Park, Ga, recall a vivacious, bold teenager who was thrilled to have attained a total-journey scholarship to examine aerospace engineering at Georgia Tech. But that girl’s name was Sharon Marshall. And there was some thing off about her romance with her father, Warren Marshall, who wouldn’t enable her converse on the mobile phone but also took out a full-site yearbook ad congratulating her on her accomplishments—complete with a image of Sharon with a pretty seem in her eyes.
Borgman vividly usually takes us back to that time with ultra-‘80s pictures of a young lady with huge, blonde hair and even even bigger dreams. But her finest good friend back then, Jenny—who acknowledged Sharon many years later on from a Tv news phase on the mystery of her identity—also provides the film’s most harrowing anecdote about the sort of abuse Sharon routinely suffered from her father.
And that is the detail that actually sticks with you afterward: the depths of depravity “Girl in the Picture” depicts. Its interviews with figures like retired FBI Special Agent Joe Fitzpatrick may perhaps search typical and familiar, positioned in a mid-century diner above a cup of espresso. But the deeply shaken seem in his eyes as he recollects the facts of the situation is unmistakable, and sudden.